Significant Cases
City of Clovis v. Shell Oil Company, Fresno Case No. 15CECG03767
Environmental tort case involving allegations that defendant Shell Oil Company distributed nematicide containing the contaminant TCP which leached into the groundwater and contaminated the City’s wells. Tried over three months to a plaintiff’s verdict of over $20 million. After post trial motions were denied the matter settled.
Stacy Johnson-Klein v. California State University Fresno, Fresno Case No. 05CECG02645
Employment discrimination case filed by terminated Fresno State Women’s Basketball Coach
tried to a jury over eight weeks to a verdict of over $19 million, later reduced on remitittur to
approximately $6.6 million. Settled on appeal.
Rio Mesa Holdings, LLC v. Fidelity National Title Insurance Company, Fresno Case No. 13CECG00867
Breach of Contract/Bad Faith case filed by real property developer against title insurance company regarding insurance for access to property bordering the San Joaquin river tried to a jury over eight weeks resulting in a verdict of $25 million, later reduced on remitittur to approximately $4 million. On appeal.
George Santillan and Howard Santillan v. Defendant John Doe, Fresno Case No. 03CECG04480
Clergy sex abuse case tried over four weeks to a defense verdict after which a motion for new trial was granted as to one of the plaintiffs on the basis of discovery of new evidence. Affirmed on appeal. Settled before retrial.
John Doe v. John Doe I, Fresno Case No. 03CECG04486
Another clergy abuse case tried over
four weeks to a defense verdict. No appeal filed.
Diocese of San Joaquin v. David Mercer Schofield, Fresno Case No. 08CECG01425
Action by local Episcopal Diocese to recover property from breakaway faction tried to the court resulting in a judgment in favor of plaintiff requiring that accounting be performed and property be returned. Affirmed on appeal.
In re: John P. McCann and Elizabeth A. McCann Trust, Fresno Case No. 11CEPR00871
Complicated trust and estate dispute involving estate valued at over $10 million. Claims of misappropriation, undue influence, fraud. Disputes regarding validity and interpretation of trust and amending instruments. Tried to the court over several weeks. Judgment issued in favor of petitioners for over $2 million and other relief. Appeal filed an dismissed.
Victor Garay and Olga Lopez Garay v. Greyhound Lines, Inc., Fresno Case No. 10CECG03185
Personal injury action arising out of Greyhound bus crash on Highway 99 tried over six weeks to a jury to a defense verdict. Motion for new trial granted on the basis of insufficient evidence in support of the verdict. New trial order affirmed on appeal.
Daniel Horsford v. California State University Fresno, Fresno Case No. 600186-1
Mulitple plaintiff reverse discrimination case tried over eight weeks to a plaintiffs’ verdict of approximately $5 million. Remitittur issued on motion for new trial. New trial order affirmed on appeal.
Hongham Souvannarath v. David Hadden, M.D., et al., Fresno Case No. 633425.4
Petition for writ of mandate/prohibition arising out of the jailing of petitioner for having tuberculosis. Tried to the court in several phases. Writ of Mandate/Prohibition issued commanding respondents to cease the housing of persons detained for tuberculosis in the Fresno County Jail. Affirmed on appeal.
Vicken Masoyan, et al. v. H.L. Leasing, Inc., Fresno Case No. 09CECG01839
Investor class action against leasing company and its principal alleging H.L. Leasing was a fraudulent Ponzi scheme tried over four weeks to a verdict of over $50 million. After the jury trial, alter ego allegations against the principal were found by the court to be proven resulting in a award against the principal over over $50 million. Affirmed on appeal.
Gonzalez v. Union Pacific Railroad, Fresno Case No. 14CECG00134
Multiple plaintiff wrongful death action involving claims of negligence and unsafe condition of railroad crossing tried over six weeks to a jury resulting in a defense verdict. Affirmed on appeal.
American Academy of Pediatrics v. Clovis Unified School District, Fresno Case No. 12CECG02608
Attorneys’ fees awarded to plaintiff under catalyst theory for motivating changes to defendant school district’s sex education curriculum.
In re: Joseph Nieto, Fresno Case No. 580708-6
Court found prejudicial juror misconduct occurred which necessitated new trial for defendant teacher following convictions of multiple acts of felony lewd touching of school children (Pen Code § 288(a)). Affirmed on appeal.
People v. Stephen Mark Lake (2007) 156 CAL. APP. 4TH SUPP. 1
A conviction under Penal Code section 647(a) for solicitation to engage in lewd conduct requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knew or reasonably should have known that someone was likely to be present who could be offended by the requested conduct.
The CBM Group, Inc. v. Llamas (2017) 12 CAL. APP. 5TH SUPP. 34
In an unlawful detainer action, the trial court’s reliance on a 60-day notice to support defendant’s eviction based on drug use or criminal activity was misplaced, since the 60-day notice did not mention that defendant was going to be evicted for either using illegal drugs or engaging in criminal activity on the premises.